Book Review: A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson
When I first picked up A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson, I wasn’t sure what to expect. I had heard whispers of its gripping plot and thrilling mystery, but as it was my first foray into the thriller genre, I was both excited and a little nervous. Now, having turned the last page, I find myself craving more—and even contemplating a reread! With a solid 4.75 stars, this book has certainly made an impression on me.
In this compelling narrative, we follow the tenacious Pippa Fitz-Amobi, a 17-year-old student whose final year project revolves around the infamous murder case of Andie Bell. While the community has long accused Sal Singh of killing her, Pip believes he’s innocent and sets off on a quest to uncover the real truth. This theme of seeking justice in a world quick to assign blame resonates deeply, especially considering the heavy topics the book touches upon—including secrets, manipulation, and the very nature of truth. One particularly haunting quote, “Pip wished she was strong enough, but she’d learned that she wasn’t invincible; she too could break,” has stayed with me long after closing the book, as it reflects Pip’s vulnerability despite her determination.
In terms of structure, the diary-like entries and alternating perspectives drew me in, albeit with an initial adjustment period. I found the writing accessible, though there were moments—with British phrases I had to look up—when I felt myself stumbling, reminding me that this was my first full read in English. However, the rewarding sense of immersion in Pip’s world more than made up for it, and I could hardly put my phone down, even with college life demanding my attention.
The characters are what truly brought this story to life. Pip’s relentless pursuit of the truth makes her both relatable and admirable. Yet, I wished for a bit more depth in her character; at times, she felt almost archetypal, encapsulating that "good girl" trope. Conversely, Ravi, Sal’s younger brother, was an absolute delight. His warmth and humor not only added a cherished layer to the narrative but also made me root for him wholeheartedly—seriously, I’d consider marrying him after this read!
Andie Bell’s character was another intriguing twist; she’s painted as a tragic victim, but as the plot unfolds, her darkness emerges. I found it hard to empathize with her—she wasn’t the epitome of innocence after all, which raised interesting questions about how we perceive victims and villains in society.
However, despite all the gripping elements and unexpected twists, some plot points left me with a bitter taste. The manner in which suspects revealed their secrets felt almost too convenient, and the fate of Barney, the beloved pet, broke my heart into a million pieces. How could Holly Jackson do that to us?!
In summary, A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder is not only a captivating thriller but also a profound exploration of truth and morality that will keep readers on the edge of their seats. This book is perfect for anyone looking to delve into a riveting mystery, and I’d recommend it to both seasoned thriller fans and newcomers alike—just be prepared for a whirlwind of emotions along the way. As for me? I’m already feeling the urge to dive back into Little Kilton’s secrets. Who’s ready for a reread?
Discover more about A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder (A Good Girl’s Guide to M… on GoodReads >>