Review of Killer in the New Forest by Carole Cole
As someone who’s always intrigued by the delicate interplay between nature and human emotion, I was irresistibly drawn to Carole Cole’s Killer in the New Forest, the third installment in the DI Callum MacLean mysteries. Cole’s skill at weaving together an atmospheric setting with profound character exploration set my expectations high, and I was not disappointed.
From the very first chapter, I felt enveloped by the icy beauty of the New Forest in January—the frost riming the ancient heathland, the gorse bushes standing sentinel against the gray sky. Callum MacLean, a Scottish detective seeking solace from his past, embodies this juxtaposition of beauty and menace. As he attempts to settle into his new home, his plans are derailed when he discovers a mysterious body lying outside the village hall. The chilling realization that the man was already dead before being struck by a car sets the stage for a gripping exploration of social undercurrents, secrets, and hidden vendettas.
One of the book’s standout qualities is its richly layered characters. MacLean is a compelling protagonist, not just for his sharp detective skills, but for the subtle ways in which his grief shapes his worldview. His observational charm and the relationship dynamics within his team add a level of authenticity and warmth that balances the simmering tension of the plot. The villagers—each with their quirks and hidden motives—are beautifully crafted, making the New Forest feel like a character in its own right.
Cole’s writing flows seamlessly, often evoking a poetic sensibility. It’s clear she pays great attention to detail, painting vivid descriptions that allow readers to visualize the haunting landscapes. One memorable line spoke of how “darkness has no fixed address,” a reflection that resonates deeply throughout the story as Callum navigates both literal and metaphorical shadows in his new surroundings. This poignant insight about human nature enriched my reading experience and lingered long after I turned the last page.
The pacing of the story skillfully builds suspense, balancing moments of quiet contemplation with scenes of sudden tension. The investigation unfolds like a carefully knitted tapestry, each thread revealing secrets and histories that intertwine the villagers. It’s a joy to piece together the puzzle alongside Callum, even as I found myself guessing until the very end.
If you appreciate mysteries that are as much about the characters and settings as they are about the crime itself, then Killer in the New Forest is a must-read. Fans of Ann Cleeves and Elly Griffiths will find themselves engrossed in this tale of hidden truths and community dynamics.
Reading Cole’s work is not merely an exercise in unraveling a crime; it’s an emotional journey that speaks to how our past and present intertwine within the geography of our lives. This book rekindled my appreciation for the detective genre, leaving me eager for what comes next in DI Callum MacLean’s evolving story. Whether you’re a long-time fan or new to the series, this installment promises an engaging mix of intrigue and heart that will resonate with mystery lovers everywhere.